Start by skipping InMail entirely: you can recruit passive candidates on LinkedIn with personalized connection requests, content engagement, voice messages, a recruiter newsletter, multi-channel sequences, and AI-powered off-platform sourcing. Only 11% of U.S. employees are actively job hunting, while another 40% are watching for openings (Gallup, Q4 2025). The people you most want to hire won’t see your job post, so you have to go to them.
InMail - LinkedIn’s paid messaging system for reaching people outside your network - isn’t the only way to contact them. Many recruiters find it isn’t even the best way. Multi-channel tools like Pin reach the passive majority across email, LinkedIn, and SMS with 5x better response rates than industry averages, and no InMail credits required. This guide breaks down seven methods that work, with real response rate benchmarks for each.
TL;DR:
- InMail is expensive and capped. Included credits work out to roughly $4.44-$6.67 each, LinkedIn publishes no average reply rate, and recruiters who fall below a 13% response rate lose bulk sending.
- Free connection-request workflows outperform it. Personalized connection notes followed by a direct message hit 25-35% response rates with no credit cost.
- Voice notes and pre-outreach engagement lift replies. LinkedIn voice messages run 30-40% higher than text, and commenting on a candidate’s post before you DM warms the cold intro.
- Multi-channel sequences beat single-channel blasts. Combining email, LinkedIn, and SMS lifts response rates above any single channel and reaches candidates who ignore LinkedIn entirely.
- Pin reaches the passive majority. Pin sources across 850M+ profiles and delivers 5x better response rates than industry averages with email, LinkedIn, and SMS sequences, so you fill pipelines without InMail credits.
Why Are Passive Candidates Worth the Extra Effort?
Sourced candidates - the ones you proactively find and reach out to - convert to hires at significantly higher rates than inbound applicants. Industry recruiting benchmarks consistently show that job board and social site applications make up roughly half of total application volume but account for less than a quarter of actual hires. According to LinkedIn’s Future of Recruiting 2025 report, companies that prioritize proactive sourcing fill roles faster and with higher-quality candidates. Passive outreach flips the inbound ratio.
It’s straightforward math. If you’re only posting jobs on LinkedIn and waiting for applicants, you’re fishing in a small slice of the talent pool - the active job seekers. As SHRM notes, posting a job and waiting is no longer enough in a competitive labor market; the strongest teams build pipelines through proactive sourcing. Everyone else is passive. They’re employed, not browsing job boards, and invisible to your inbound pipeline. Yet in LinkedIn’s survey of 18,000 fully employed professionals, 45% said they weren’t looking but would talk to a recruiter (LinkedIn Talent Trends, 2014).
What makes passive candidates better hires? Passive candidates are typically employed, performing well in their current role, and not desperate for any offer. Evaluating your opportunity against a known alternative - their current job - they’re making a deliberate choice rather than accepting whatever comes first. That selectivity translates to better retention, stronger performance, and fewer early-stage dropoffs.
Meanwhile, the shift toward proactive sourcing keeps accelerating. Talent rediscovery - re-engaging candidates you’ve already spoken to - is becoming a primary sourcing channel as more teams invest in CRM-based pipelines. Without an active passive candidate pipeline, you’re leaving your strongest hiring channel untouched.
To recruit passive candidates effectively, you need a repeatable system: identify prospects, warm up the outreach, run a coordinated sequence across two or three channels, and follow up with new information each time. The seven methods below give you that system, with response rate benchmarks for each.
Why Is LinkedIn InMail So Expensive for Recruiters?
LinkedIn doesn’t publish an average InMail reply rate. Its analysis of tens of millions of messages sent between May 2023 and April 2024 reports only relative differences by industry and function. The one absolute number LinkedIn enforces is a 13% minimum response rate for recruiters sending 100+ InMails in 14 days. Those numbers come with a price tag that’s hard to ignore.
Recruiter Lite runs about $170 per month and gives you 30 InMail credits - roughly $5.67 per message. Recruiter Corporate is quote-only; Vendr buyer data puts it around $8,000-$12,000 per seat per year for 150 credits a month, or about $4.44-$6.67 per credit. Once you burn through your monthly allocation, there’s no published price for extra credits.
Do the math.
Even at a 20% reply rate, well above LinkedIn’s 13% floor, you’re spending about $28 per reply on Recruiter Lite - and that’s just a reply, not a hire. If 1 in 5 replies converts to a phone screen, and 1 in 4 screens converts to an interview, you’re looking at roughly $570 in InMail cost per interview. On high-volume roles, those numbers destroy your cost-per-hire budget fast.
Unused InMail credits roll over month to month, but the bank is capped at 4x your monthly allocation (120 on Lite, 600 per Corporate seat), and anything above the cap expires. And credits get refunded only if the recipient replies within 90 days. Credits are gone the moment an InMail lands in someone’s “Other” inbox unseen. And when LinkedIn shows “You have no InMail credits left,” your only native options are waiting for next month’s refresh or paying for a bigger plan. Our roundup of cheaper options than LinkedIn Recruiter breaks down what each plan actually costs.
LinkedIn InMail Response Rate vs. Free Outreach Methods
InMail has no published average response rate, only LinkedIn’s 13% floor, versus 25-35% for free personalized connection requests, and multi-channel outreach performs best of all. Here is how the main LinkedIn outreach methods stack up on cost, response rate, and scale:
| Outreach Method | Cost | Response Rate | Scale |
|---|---|---|---|
| InMail (recruiting) | ~$4.44-$6.67/credit | No published average (13% floor) | 30-150/month (credit-limited) |
| Connection request + DM | Free | 25-35% | ~100/week (platform limit) |
| LinkedIn voice message | Free (1st-degree only) | 30-40% higher than text | Manual (1-2 min each) |
| Multi-channel (email + LinkedIn + SMS) | Varies by tool | Highest of these methods | Hundreds/day of automated email, plus LinkedIn and SMS tasks |
| Pin AI-powered outreach | Free plan; paid from $99/month | 5x industry average | 850M+ profiles, automated email sequences |
How To Source More Candidates on LinkedIn
7 Ways to Recruit Passive Candidates Without InMail
1. Send Personalized Connection Requests
Personalized connection requests, which name something concrete from a candidate’s profile rather than defaulting to a generic pitch, average a 45% acceptance rate versus 15% for generic ones - a gap measured across 500,000+ requests. Once someone accepts, you can message them directly for free - no InMail required. A follow-up direct message after acceptance averages a 25-35% response rate, which often outperforms InMail for recruiting. In Pin’s data on 200,000+ LinkedIn messages sent after a connection request (January 2025 to September 2026), candidates replied 18.1% of the time. That’s 3.6x the 5.09% reply rate on 8,800,000+ email touches over the same period.
With only 300 characters for the connection note, every word matters. Name something specific: a project they shipped, a post they wrote, a company transition they made. Generic notes like “I’d love to connect and discuss opportunities” get ignored. Specific notes like “Saw your talk on scaling Kubernetes at [Conference] - we’re solving a similar problem and I’d love to chat” get accepted.
One important constraint: LinkedIn limits you to roughly 100 connection requests per week. Go over that threshold consistently and you risk restrictions on your account. Quality over quantity isn’t just advice here - it’s a platform requirement.
Here’s a template that works consistently:
“Hi [Name] - your work on [specific project/accomplishment] at [Company] caught my eye. I’m a recruiter working on a [role type] position that matches your background. Would love to connect.”
That’s under 300 characters. It’s specific. And it gives the candidate a reason to accept beyond “this person wants something from me.” Compare that to the default LinkedIn connection message - which is literally blank - or the generic “I’d like to add you to my professional network.” Specificity is the single biggest predictor of acceptance rate.
2. Engage With Their Content Before You Reach Out
Before sending a connection request, spend 60 seconds on the candidate’s profile. Like a recent post. Leave a thoughtful comment on an article they shared. React to a career update. This isn’t manipulation - it’s context. When your connection request arrives, they’ll recognize your name from their notification feed.
This approach takes more time per candidate, but the conversion rate justifies it. Candidates who’ve seen your name once or twice before you reach out are significantly more likely to accept your request and respond to your message. Think of it as warming up a cold outreach - the same principle that makes remarketing ads work in marketing.
Practical workflow: set aside 20 minutes each morning to engage with 10-15 target candidates’ content. Comment on their posts with genuine observations, not “Great post!” Add something substantive. Two days later, send the connection request. You’ll notice the difference immediately. If a candidate works at a company you’re unfamiliar with, quickly find and review the company’s LinkedIn page first. Understanding their employer brand and team size helps you write a connection note that demonstrates genuine interest.
3. Use LinkedIn Voice Messages
LinkedIn voice messages generate 30-40% higher reply rates than standard text messages, according to documented recruiter case studies. They’re available to anyone in your 1st-degree network - no InMail credits needed. And almost nobody uses them for recruiting, which means your voice note stands out in an inbox full of templated text.
Why do voice messages work so well? They’re impossible to fake at scale. Someone who receives dozens of copy-paste InMails every week can tell in three seconds that a real person recorded a message specifically for them. That authenticity cuts through the noise of automated sequences. Keep your voice message under 60 seconds. Hit the same three points as a text message: why them specifically, what the role is, and a low-pressure ask.
One caveat: voice messages only work with 1st-degree connections. So you’ll need to connect first (using method #1), then follow up with a voice note if they don’t respond to your initial text message. Think of voice messages as your second touch - not your first.
Script for a 45-second recruiting voice message: “Hi [Name], this is [Your Name] - I’m a recruiter working with [Company]. I noticed your background in [specific skill/project] and wanted to reach out directly instead of sending another text message you might scroll past. We’re building a [team/product] and I think your experience with [specific thing] would be a strong fit. No pressure at all - just wanted to put a voice to the name. Feel free to message me back or grab 15 minutes on my calendar. Talk soon.”
4. Build a Recruiter Newsletter on LinkedIn
At a 42% open rate, LinkedIn newsletters run double the 21% average for traditional email newsletters. They’re a long game, but a powerful one. When passive candidates subscribe to your newsletter, they’ve opted into hearing from you regularly. You don’t need to chase them; they come to you.
What should a recruiter newsletter cover? Not job postings. Publish career insights, salary benchmarks, industry trends, and hiring market updates specific to the roles you recruit for. Naming your newsletter something like “The DevOps Hiring Market - Weekly” and sharing real comp data and team structures will attract exactly the kind of passive candidates you want to reach.
Over six months, that compound effect becomes real. After consistent publishing, you’ll have a subscriber base of hundreds or thousands of candidates in your niche. When a new role opens, you can mention it naturally within your content. Subscribers who’ve been reading for months already trust you - the “cold” outreach problem disappears entirely.
Getting started is straightforward. Go to your LinkedIn profile, click “Write article,” and select “Create a newsletter” from the publishing options. Choose a name that signals value to your target audience - not your company name. “Cloud Engineering Hiring Trends” attracts candidates. “Acme Corp Recruiting Updates” doesn’t. Publish on a consistent schedule, whether that’s weekly or biweekly. LinkedIn notifies all your followers when you launch a newsletter, giving you an initial subscriber boost.
5. Join and Participate in LinkedIn Groups
Most LinkedIn Groups today are ghost towns of promotional spam - a far cry from what they were in 2015. But niche, well-moderated groups still exist, especially in specialized fields like cybersecurity, DevOps, healthcare IT, and financial engineering. Finding active groups and contributing consistently is the entire strategy here - not posting job ads.
When you answer questions, share useful resources, and engage in discussions, passive candidates see you as a knowledgeable peer rather than another recruiter in their inbox. That reputation makes your eventual outreach land differently. “Hey, I’m the person who helped you debug that Terraform issue in the AWS Users Group” is a fundamentally different opening than a cold InMail.
Start with 2-3 groups where your target candidates are active. Commit to one thoughtful post or comment per week in each group. Don’t pitch. Don’t post jobs. Build credibility first, then reach out to individual members who’d be a fit.
How do you find active groups? Search for your target role or skill (like “data engineering” or “product management”), filter by Groups, and sort by activity. Look for groups with recent posts - within the last week - and member counts between 5,000 and 50,000. Too small and there’s nobody to reach. Too large and the group is typically overrun with spam that moderators can’t keep up with.
6. Use Multi-Channel Outreach (Email + LinkedIn + SMS)
Cold email reply rates dropped to 5.1% in 2025 - down from 7% in 2024, according to Engagekit’s 2025 LinkedIn Response Benchmarks. LinkedIn direct messages alone average 10-17% response rates. Neither channel is enough on its own. Combine email, LinkedIn, and SMS into a coordinated sequence, though, and response rates climb substantially. Different people check different channels at different times, so a candidate who ignores your LinkedIn message may respond immediately to the same ask via email.
A typical multi-channel sequence runs across five touchpoints. Start with a connection request on Day 1, then a follow-up LinkedIn message on Day 3. Email on Day 5. A second LinkedIn touchpoint on Day 8. Senior or hard-to-reach candidates can get an optional SMS on Day 10. Each message builds on the last but can also stand alone if the candidate only sees one.
Pin integrates with 120+ ATSes and sources from 850M+ profiles. It brings all three outreach channels into a single sequence: email steps send automatically, while LinkedIn and SMS steps queue as recruiter tasks. The result is 5x better response rates than industry averages, without copying and pasting across three separate tools. Try Pin’s automated outreach.
Consistency in messaging across channels is key - but without being repetitive. Your LinkedIn message and your email should tell the same story but use different angles. Something from the candidate’s profile fits the LinkedIn message. Email suits a team detail or compensation range better. The SMS - if you use it - is the shortest touchpoint: “Hi [Name], sent you a note on LinkedIn about the [Role] at [Company]. Worth 15 minutes?” Each channel adds context rather than repeating the same pitch.
Timing matters too. Space messages 2-3 days apart so the candidate feels pursued, not stalked. Always give them an opt-out. Showing respect by offering an easy out - “No worries if now isn’t the right time” - counterintuitively increases response rates. Check our AI-powered LinkedIn outreach playbook for a detailed look at structuring outreach across channels.
7. Use AI-Powered Sourcing Tools to Find Candidates Off-Platform
According to LinkedIn’s Future of Recruiting 2025 report, 37% of organizations are actively integrating or experimenting with generative AI in recruiting, and those who do report a 20% reduction in workload. AI-powered sourcing tools take the “without InMail” approach a step further: they find candidate contact information - personal email, phone number - so you can reach passive talent on channels LinkedIn doesn’t control.
In our experience, the teams that drop InMail as their primary outreach channel consistently close the same roles faster than those who keep it at the center. Not because InMail is broken - a 20% recruiting reply rate is decent - but because single-channel dependency is fragile. When LinkedIn tightens credit allocations or tweaks its algorithm, teams without an off-platform pipeline stall. Recruiters who pair connection-request workflows with email and SMS reach candidates on less crowded channels. According to the 2026 Pin user survey, recruiters using multi-channel sequences fill positions in an average of 14 days - the fastest time-to-fill we’ve measured. The biggest unlock isn’t just a higher response rate; candidates who get a thoughtful outreach on two or three channels convert into hires at a meaningfully better rate than those messaged only on LinkedIn.
Pin’s AI scans 850M+ candidate profiles with 100% coverage across North America and Europe. Instead of being limited to LinkedIn’s messaging system, you get direct contact details and can run outreach through email and SMS alongside LinkedIn. The result is 5x better response rates than industry averages. Pin also saves recruiters an average of 12 hours per week on sourcing and outreach combined - equivalent to 1.5 extra workdays reclaimed every week.
“I jumped into Pin solo toward the end of 2025 and closed out the year with over $1M in billings during just the final 4 months - no team, no agency. The sourcing data is incredible, scanning 850M+ profiles with recruiter-level precision to uncover perfect-fit candidates I’d never find otherwise. Best of all, the outreach feels genuinely personalized and non-generic, driving sky-high reply rates where candidates even thank me for the thoughtful messages.”
Nick Poloni, President, Cascadia Search Group
For recruiters doing high-volume passive outreach at scale, Pin is the clear choice. Manual InMail workflows cap out at 30-150 messages per month. Pin’s multi-channel sequences handle hundreds of personalized outreach touches per day without burning credits or restricting which candidates you can contact.
For a full breakdown of tools that go beyond LinkedIn’s native features, explore our guide to engaging passive candidates without spamming.
How Do Recruiters Find Contact Details for Passive Candidates Off LinkedIn?
Recruiters find passive candidates’ email addresses and phone numbers with contact-data tools that match a profile to verified personal details, so nobody has to research every profile by hand. That’s what makes contacting passive candidates possible without InMail, and it’s the step most LinkedIn-only workflows skip.
Manual research is slow. You check a personal site, a GitHub README, a conference speaker page, or guess an email format and run it through a verifier. It works for five candidates. Fifty of them eats the whole week.
Sourcing platforms collapse that into one step. In Pin, you search across 850M+ profiles and pull a verified email or phone number for each match at 1 contact credit per lookup. Emailing passive candidates then runs as an automated sequence, with LinkedIn and SMS steps queued as tasks for the recruiter to send.
Some candidates rarely check email at all. With those people, the LinkedIn connection request and a short SMS task carry the sequence, while email becomes the backup channel. Covering all three is how you reach people who ignore any single one.
What Makes Passive Candidates Actually Respond?
Passive candidates respond to short messages that name something specific about them, connect their background to the role in one line, and ask for very little, like a 15-minute call. LinkedIn’s own InMail data backs this up.
Shorter messages consistently outperform longer ones. Messages under 400 characters receive response rates 22% above average, while messages over 1,200 characters perform 11% below average, according to LinkedIn’s analysis of InMails sent from May 2021 to April 2022 (LinkedIn Talent Blog). Brevity wins with connection request notes and direct messages too.
Only 10% of InMails in that dataset came in under 400 characters, while 46% ran past 800. Most recruiters are writing the length that performs worst.
But length alone doesn’t determine success. The three elements that consistently predict whether a passive candidate responds are:
Specificity: Name something concrete about them. Their current project, a post they wrote, a career transition they made. “Your background is impressive” is noise. “Your migration from monolith to microservices at [Company]” is a signal that you did your homework.
Relevance: Connect their background to the opportunity in one sentence. Don’t describe the role in detail - just the overlap. “We’re solving a similar scaling problem and need someone who’s done it before” tells them why you’re reaching out to them specifically.
Low friction: Ask for a 15-minute call, not a formal interview. Suggest a quick chat, not a multi-step process. Lower commitment in the ask drives higher acceptance rates. You can always expand the conversation once they respond.
AI-Assisted Messages - LinkedIn’s own feature for recruiter outreach - produce a 44% higher acceptance rate than non-AI messages (LinkedIn 2025 Hiring Release Wave 1). That feature personalizes message drafts from candidate profiles, and LinkedIn’s best practices for AI-assisted messages lean on the same fundamentals, specificity and relevance, that drive replies on the free channels above. Worth testing if you’re already on a Recruiter plan, though it still requires InMail credits. Similar - or better - results are achievable with the methods in this guide, at zero credit cost.
Top Sourcing Strategies for Finding the Best Candidates
How to Build a Follow-Up Sequence That Gets Replies
A second follow-up message on LinkedIn produces an additional 4% response lift, and spacing 2-3 follow-ups 4-7 days apart can push cumulative response rates to 20-30% or higher (Engagekit 2025 Benchmarks). Most recruiters send one message and give up. That single-touch approach leaves significant response potential on the table.
Here’s a follow-up framework that works across any LinkedIn outreach method:
Day 1: Initial connection request with a personalized note. Reference something specific about their background.
Day 3-4 (after acceptance): First direct message. Short, specific, and focused on one role. Include the company name, what makes the role interesting, and a low-friction ask. Keep it under 400 characters.
Day 7-8: Second touch. Don’t repeat your first message - add new information. Share a relevant detail about the team, the tech stack, the company’s recent growth, or a specific challenge the role would address. “Wanted to add some context” works better than “Just following up.”
Day 10-12: Final touch. Keep it brief and give them an easy out. Something like: “Totally understand if the timing isn’t right. If you’re ever curious about [Company], I’m happy to chat - no strings attached.” This message often gets the highest response rate because it removes pressure.
Tuesday through Thursday mornings are the best days to send LinkedIn messages. January, April, and July tend to produce the highest response rates across industries (Engagekit, 2025). Avoid Mondays (inbox overload) and Fridays (mentally checked out).
One principle matters more than timing or templates: each follow-up should add value, not just repeat the ask. If your second message says “Just checking in” or “Circling back,” you’ve wasted a touch. Make every message count.
Short. Specific. New information every time. That’s the framework.
If you want templates to adapt, the principles from cold recruiting emails translate directly to LinkedIn messages.
Key Takeaways
Seven methods to recruit passive candidates on LinkedIn without InMail credits - here’s the summary:
- Passive candidates convert at significantly higher rates than inbound applicants. Proactive sourcing consistently outperforms job board applications.
- InMail costs roughly $4.44-$6.67 per included credit, and LinkedIn publishes no average reply rate, only a 13% minimum. The ROI math often doesn’t work, especially for high-volume hiring.
- Personalized connection requests hit 45% acceptance rates - three times higher than generic requests - and follow-up DMs average 25-35% response rates for free.
- Voice messages boost reply rates 30-40% over standard text messages. They work best as a second touch after connecting.
- Multi-channel outreach outperforms any single channel. Combining email, LinkedIn, and SMS in a coordinated sequence is how recruiters using tools like Pin reach 5x better response rates than industry averages.
- Follow up 2-3 times, spaced 4-7 days apart. Each message should add new information, not just repeat the ask.
- candidate sourcing platforms expand your reach beyond LinkedIn’s messaging system entirely. Pin scans 850M+ profiles and provides direct contact details for outreach across every channel.
Reach passive candidates with Pin’s multi-channel outreach →
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best way to contact passive candidates on LinkedIn without InMail?
Send a personalized connection request with a 300-character note referencing something specific about the candidate’s background. Personalized requests average a 45% acceptance rate versus 15% for generic ones. Once connected, follow up with a direct message - this two-step approach hits 25-35% response rates, often outperforming InMail for recruiting.
What is the average response rate for LinkedIn InMails?
There’s no official average InMail response rate. Its analysis of tens of millions of messages reports only relative lifts, such as +22% for messages under 400 characters and +37% for Open to Work candidates. LinkedIn does require recruiters to maintain at least a 13% response rate on accounts sending more than 100 InMails to preserve account standing. For comparison, personalized connection requests followed by direct messages hit 25-35% reply rates at zero credit cost.
How much does LinkedIn InMail cost per message?
Each included LinkedIn InMail credit costs roughly $4.44-$6.67, depending on your plan. Recruiter Lite runs $170/month for 30 credits, and Recruiter Corporate is quote-only at around $8,000-$12,000 per seat per year (Vendr) for 150 credits a month. LinkedIn doesn’t publish a price for extra credits. Unused credits roll over up to 4x your monthly allocation.
Do AI sourcing tools work better than LinkedIn InMail for recruiting?
AI sourcing tools consistently outperform InMail for passive candidate outreach. Pin’s multi-channel sequences across email, LinkedIn, and SMS deliver 5x better response rates than industry averages. AI tools also provide direct contact information (email, phone), so you’re not limited to LinkedIn’s messaging system.
What is a passive candidate in recruitment?
A passive candidate is a professional who is currently employed and not actively job hunting, but open to the right move if a recruiter makes a compelling case. LinkedIn’s global survey classed three-quarters of fully employed professionals as passive (2014), and Gallup’s Q4 2025 data shows only 11% of U.S. employees actively looking. Passive candidates are typically reached through direct outreach, referrals, and networking rather than job board applications. Because they are not browsing openings, they tend to be selective - which is also why they often become stronger, longer-tenured hires than active applicants.
What is an example of a passive candidate?
A senior backend engineer who has spent four years at a fintech company, just shipped a major migration, and hasn’t updated their resume is a classic passive candidate. They aren’t applying anywhere, but a specific note about that migration and a role with a bigger scope could get a reply.
What percentage of the workforce is passive candidates?
Most of it. Gallup’s Q4 2025 survey found only 11% of U.S. employees actively looking for a job, with another 40% watching for openings. LinkedIn’s older global study of 18,000 professionals in 26 countries (2014) put 75% of the workforce in the passive group, and 45% said they’d talk to a recruiter even though they weren’t looking. Only 15% were fully closed to recruiter outreach.
How do you find passive candidates without LinkedIn?
Search the places where people show their work: GitHub, Stack Overflow, patent filings, publications, conference talks, and niche communities. Then use a sourcing platform to get verified contact details and reach them by email and SMS. Pin aggregates those sources into 850M+ profiles, so you can find and contact passive candidates without a LinkedIn Recruiter seat.
How many follow-up messages should I send on LinkedIn?
Send 2-3 follow-up messages spaced 4-7 days apart. A second follow-up produces roughly a 4% additional response lift, and cumulative response rates of 20-30% are achievable with a well-spaced sequence (Engagekit, 2025). Each follow-up should add new information about the role or company rather than simply repeating your original ask.